Research: Who were the Medici’s

This is a very late addition to my blog as I am literally submitting for assessment tomorrow but I cannot forget to add an albeit very brief piece on the Medici family who I have read about so many times during this course.

In essence the Medici family were the ruling family of Florence for many generations and also Tuscany for a period  and they include two popes – Leo X and Clement VII.  The family were originally bankers going back to the 14th century and were founded by one Giovanni di Bicci de’ Medici who was born in 1397.   It seems the family business was based on cloth and silk manufacturing as well as banking – I confess to not being aware of the textile background to the family before this research. As well as banking the family were also politicians which of course makes sense with their eventual rise to power.

Giovanni founded the bank that eventually became the Pope’s bank such was its power.  Giovanni also apparently introduced a new taxation method as well as commissioned art and buildings by the likes of Brunelleschi or Donatello and that is where I have first come across the family – the Medici’s were wealthy and well-known patrons of the arts throughout the Renaissance and Baroque periods as I discovered through my research into Artemisia Gentileschi.  Two of the Medici son’s albeit different generations had a tomb made for them by none other than Michelangelo  – the Medici Tombs of Florence and this further displays the regard in which the family were held or at least the power that they held at the time.

During the lifetime of Giovanni’s son the bank expanded as far as London, Rome, Barcelona and Bruges and also into Rhodes and Cologne but then it started to go wrong during the next 2 generations and due to a combination of corruption, bad investment and bad management it collapsed in 1494.

The last Medici ruler died in 1737 without an heir but many of the ruling families of Europe can trace their lineage back to this family – one descendant, Catherine became Queen of France as the wife of Henry II  and 3 out of their 4 sons also became Kings of France.

It is a family which is rich in history and with tales of corruption and power and certainly money but from an art history point of view it is a family who commissioned some of the great works of the Renaissance and Baroque eras.

As I write this brief blog I am now more curious about the Medici family with both their personal history and how far the genes reach throughout the European families of today but also about the influence on the arts and the sheer power they held through the centuries and I have no doubt that I will do further research as my studies into art history continue beyond this course.

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

A+E Networks Digital. 2017. The Medici Family [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from: http://www.history.com/topics/medici-family

Encyclopedia Britannica. 2017.  Medici Family Italian Family [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  https://www.britannica.com/topic/Medici-family

Sansom, I. 8 May 2010.  Great Dynasties of the World:  The Medici Family [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/may/08/great-dynasties-medici-family

Posted in Notes, Research & Reflection | Tagged | Leave a comment

Long-lost Caravaggio ….

This is an unexpected blog concerning an article discovered as I have been checking over my essay in preparation for assessment!

caraaIn 1599 Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio painted Judith Beheading Holofernes which is based on the biblical story.  Now it appears the second long lost version of this work has possibly been discovered in the hands of private owners in France according to a French newspaper – it is certainly known that Caravaggio painted two versions with on on display at the National Gallery of Ancient Art in Italy.

However according to the article I have discovered online  the second version has been missing since the 17th century … until 2016 that is and until its authenticity can be estabilshed the Ministry of Culture in France has banned it from leaving the country.  It seems an American museum has expressed an interest in the piece already despite there being no direct evidence which confirms its provenance.

According to the article a specialist in Caravaggio, one Mina Gregori, has not found evidence of Caravaggio’s hand or workmanship in this recently discovered work.  However the French paper Le Figaro has pointed out that she has been misguided or incorrect in some of her recent attributions so her words cannot be taken as confirmation that it is not the lost work and clearly more investigations will have been ongoing since the article was written in March 2016 and these include Giuseppe Porzio and Maria Cristina Terzaghi who are Italian experts and Caravaggio experts.

If this is indeed the lost second version of Caravaggio’s masterpiece the painting could be valued at $113 million US dollars if it were to be sold but this could be a conservative estimate for an incredible art work.

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

Munso-Alonso, L. April 2016.  Long-Lost Caravaggio Painting Possibly Found in France [online].  [Date accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  https://news.artnet.com/market/long-lost-caravaggio-found-france-466646

 

Posted in Notes, Research & Reflection | Tagged | Leave a comment

Summary or overview of the final 3 chapters from 1900 to post World War 2

My tutor suggested in her final feedback I did a summary of the final 3 chapters with a concentration on 4 headings:

  • Art as a social commentary
  • Art as a cultural property
  • How politics shapes art and art shapes politics
  • Learning about the past to inform the present and shape the future

These 4 headings could apply to the history of art as a whole and so I base my answer as a reflection on the whole course but with my thoughts on my notes of the final 3 chapters.  My headings have made me consider my responses carefully which are based on my notes of the last chapters as well as my notes throughout the course.

Art as a social commentary

Art is a reflection of society due to it being a visual record of events and this applies down the centuries.  There can be no doubt of the changes that began to take place socially at the turn of the 20th century and which gathered pace due to the devastation of the two World Wars and eventually resulted in a very consumer and materialistic society.  The art of each period mentioned in the chapters reflected those changes including breaking with the traditions that dated back to the 14th century – the use of colour, perspective, form and line changed from that of naturalism and realism to expressionism, surrealism and abstraction in all the variances of style.  Artists observed society in the same way as before but reflected the social changes and were consequentially highly influenced by them – this can be seen for example in the work of the documentary photographers or the Mexican muralists.  The artists were also influenced hugely by the advances in science and technology as well as the psychologists which were all a part of the ever changing societies of the period.  Art is literally a window into the differing eras and therefore the commentary of the artists who were part of those societies.

Art as a cultural property

The Mexican muralists are perhaps the best example of this because the art reflects their culture and also the era in which it was painted and this is also apparent in the different countries worldwide. I question whether art is a cultural property or part of cultural identity and for this I must look to the past as the art of the Dutch Golden Age can be distinguished from that of a 17th century Italian Baroque painter in the same way that the art of the English landscape painters of England and American each had their different styles – for example the English Romantic painters and the Hudson River School painters who were influenced by the former but there is a distinct variance in style which reflected their landscapes and culture.  African and Oceanic art influenced the Cubists and Expressionists but these two forms of art very much form the cultural identity of the people and in our multicultural society of today we witness the different artistic styles of many different countries or religions and each is part of their cultural identity and each artistic style is the cultural property of that country or people.   The consumerist society of America post-World War II influenced very directly the culture and society of firstly America and then England and in turn influenced the art – the Pop Art culture is almost iconic for many in the same way that Cubism is very much a European style.

david-mcneil-fun-with-acrylic-paintingAt this point I must stress the fact that culture does not just refer to country or to a specific group of people but of course to religion and religious art is very much part of cultural property as it has been throughout the ages – this acrylic painting by David McNeil from a Facebook group, who has given me kind permission to share his work, is an example as it is a Christian image and any member of the Christian community would say that this represents their culture.  Art from the various religions around the world is instantly recognisable – statues of Buddha for instance or the different architectural styles between churches, mosques or temples.  This particular painting despite its relatively simple composition also speaks of a very strong message of the Christian church, without the need for words,  as it is concerning the Crucifixion and the purple cloth with its reference to royalty due to the fact Christ was believed to the King of Heaven. This painting also crosses into art as a social commentary in the fact that the art is associated with a social community, albeit a religious one,  and speaks of the beliefs of that community.

How politics shape art and art shapes politics

Politics has a very direct influence on the art world whether it is political politics or religious politics.  Politics shaped art particularly regarding  being used for propaganda purposes during the political unstable era of the first half the 20th century and a prime example is the Futurists of pre-World War I eventually distanced themselves after the war due to the increasing  membership of far-right organisations.  Politics uses the visual message of art to be able to inform the people affected by the manifestos but in the same way the artists or the art reflects the people of society and the feelings of those people and this in turn can shape the politics of the era.  In effect art of any nature can be used as a political tool in a visual form in the same way that the stained glass windows or art of the Catholic Counter Reformation was able to spread the message that the way of the Catholic Church was the right way.  Pablo Picasso’s Guernica is one of the most powerful paintings of the Spanish Civil War as it speaks of the devastation caused the Nazi’s – the art tells the general public of events that have happened without necessarily using words and therefore the message can be stronger and evoke more emotions and this in turn can be used by the political parties to stir up support for their party or hatred for another party or group of people.  The posters of the World War I in England were used for moral boosting messages by the political parties and this happens repeatedly throughout the 20th century and indeed into the 21st century in the newspapers. A further example is  protest art, including that of the Futurists, that had a direct effect on the politics because it was the people’s way of getting their message across over what they wanted to their politicians.

Learning about the past to inform the present and shape the future

Firstly I must think of the rejection at the beginning of the 20th century of all forms of naturalism and the break away from the traditions of the 14th century – yes this is not learning about the past directly but to be able to break away or reject something you must first be knowledgeable about it.  Artists over the 20th century have sought to find new ways of expressing themselves using new technology and inventions but the artists also sought new ways of exhibiting without being constricted to the established galleries or exhibitions which were the accepted way of becoming known in the past – art has become more accessible.  I am studying art history in order to inform my studies and shape my future and I feel that to learn about the artists of the past or their art means I have a clearer understanding of not just the paintings or the sculpture but also the political or economic and for me possibly most importantly the social history which shaped the art and influenced it.  The artists of the 20th century wanted to express their inner feelings or express what they felt and saw around them but they also had to be aware of the past conventions and history in order to develop the new styles or the new ideas which formed their future.

I do not feel that the future can be shaped or the present can be informed if the past is not a part of the lessons – to look at a Cubist or Surrealist painting you must first learn of the eras that preceded that.  I could not understand Minimalist art or Colour Field art or abstraction or Expressionism if I had first not studied the Romantics, the Realists, Rococo, Medieval or Greek art or any of the styles and eras in between and knowing what the Western Classical Canon is – to be able to understand and appreciate modern art and to be able to shape your own artistic future you must study the art of your predecessors.

 

Posted in Coursework, Notes, Part 5, Research & Reflection | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Notes and questions regarding ways that artistic representation expresses cultural values – Tutor Report Assignment 5

My tutor, in her report on my final assignment, has asked me to reflect on the ways that artistic expression represent cultural values and this was in response to the Mexican muralists and their celebration of their mixed-race heritage (mestizaje) and how muralism as an art form was promoted regarding social and political engagement – at the time of writing this is incredibly relevant as I am writing this just 2 days after the inauguration of a new American president.

Reflecting firstly on how artistic expression represents cultural values is I feel, based on my reading and research, that art is a reflection on our individual cultures and our cultures directly influence the art.  For the Mexican muralists their heritage was vitally important to them and murals emerged as a form of art reflecting the way they wished to be defined in much the same way as any culture the world over uses their art to display their cultural identity and this has happened since before language was even developed.

My tutor then asked the following questions:

  • What is the goal of art? Art has no one single goal – in different eras and centuries it meant different things including promoting the stories of the bible to the illiterate poor in past centuries and moving forward as a way of getting the message across regarding a certain political or social movement or just simply to record every day life as an artist witnessed.  Throughout this course I have come to the conclusion, based on my reading, that the goal of art was to somehow inform the viewer about something whether it was a portrait, particularly before the invention of photography, a landscape, a biblical scene or a mythological scene with a moral message or a still life with all the hidden iconography. However some art is just purely done for aesthetic purposes and here I think of the floral works of art although even they convey a message about the time in which they were painted.
  • To what extent is art supposed to be autonomous and separated from everyday life? I don’t think it is separate from every day life, or at least it isn’t in our modern era – art is a part of life everywhere you look with digital art of all forms and artists of all genres and also with the proliferation of more traditional forms of art such as paintings and sculpture which can be seen everywhere from your local town centre to the park and the museums, homes and shops or places of worship.  In historical terms art was more separated due to artists holding different levels of status throughout the centuries and this includes the craftsman and the architects as well as the sculptors and painters.  However in terms of autonomy I do feel increasingly that art does govern itself and acts independently although historically this was not the case – art and artists have increasingly sought the freedom to be independent of galleries and commissions due in part in this modern era of high commission fees from galleries and increasingly high expenses for exhibitions and art fairs.  Artists are having to be independent and find ways of marketing their work which is financially affordable particularly to the proverbial struggling artist. If I consider the word ‘supposed’ in the question art is supposed to be very self governing but the lure of the galleries and exhibitions, despite the expenses or commissions involved, is still irresistible as they are still a way of the general public getting to know your work, as well as securing further commissions,  despite the independence that is so desperately craved and it is the galleries and exhibitions that take away the independence of the artist and art.  Art is however autonomous, but not separate from everyday life in that it is continually evolving and changing style in tune with the social, political and economic times – as I review the words I have just written I must come to the conclusion that art is not autonomous at all due to the fact it cannot be if it is influenced so much by the world that exists in which it is part of.
  • Does art that has a function cross the line from art to propaganda or is there a hazier area between the two?  Yes I think art that has a function can cross that line – art has been used as propaganda throughout history if you define ‘propaganda’ to get across a point of view whether political or religious and I immediately think of the art of the Catholic Counter Reformation right up to the work of the Mexican muralists or propaganda posters of the two World Wars. debbie-thornhill-urban-sketchers-la-womens-marchArt that has a function does not necessarily cross that line but yes there can be that hazy border – this piece by Debbie Thornhill, who  has given me very kind permission to reproduce her urban sketch, of the Woman’s March in Los Angeles that have took place this weekend in response to President Trump’s election and the feared erosion of women’s rights.   I do not feel it is propaganda because it was done as a visual record of that march sketched by an eye witness although it could be conceived as being in that hazy border because it records a political event – I have not asked Debbie if she was a participant or merely an observer because maybe that is where the art crosses the line i.e. if the artist is a direct participant in the event unfolding or the political movement then does the art become propaganda? or if the artist is merely an observer is the art function merely as a visual record? david-lowther-urban-sketchersOn the other hand David Lowther, who has again given me kind permission to use his ink and collage sketch, has produced a piece of art that has a function in the sense that it records the Manchester Bridgewater Hall as he has seen it – it is a sketched equivalent of a documentary photograph but it does not cross any line into propaganda and is purely a visual record and that is its sole function.
  • Also considering the value of public art in society – what does public art accomplish? Public art can be purely decorative for aesthetic purposes and it can even cause controversy if the public feels the money should be spent elsewhere particularly in the austerity of the modern day.  Public art can accomplish speaking of a message or honouring a valued member of the community or in the case of murals it can simply brighten and lift the visual appearance of an area which in turn can be morally uplifting.  Public art takes all forms and is seen in every different size that is possible from light installations to small sculptures – it can literally be anything that has been planned and executed with the intention of being seen by the general public and can evoke a range of emotions and responses.  As I write I reflect on the National Memorial Arboretum of Staffordshire and the huge variety of memories in different forms – the NMA is a place of peace, reflection and beauty as well has having areas that are sombre but the whole area is one of reflection and somewhere you see a wide variety of groups of people or individuals with a range of emotions exhibited from sorrow through to joy.  Public art evokes emotion and it makes people think and look and can convey a message either through subtle means or blatant propaganda.
  • If muralism is monumental and public, how are its conditions different from small, private works of art that are made for consumption by the art market and institutions like museums?  Muralism is completely different due to the fact it is large and it is public and therefore seen by so many but private works of art may be only seen by very few people depending where they are to be displayed.  Works of art purchased by museums may be on display permanently or may be on temporary display in others if loaned out to them and this again must have its own set of conditions.  Many smaller works of art may be done without a specific patron and done for the open art market but many are specially commissioned and this is where I note the similarity to the public works of art as the majority will be specifically commissioned due to the size and expense involved – at this point I question whether similar financial amounts could potentially exchange hands despite the difference in scale.  The difference in the two differing art genres is when the works of art are done for the aforesaid open market as the artist is working independently and is free to choose the subject and style but if a piece of art is commissioned then the artist may only have the freedom of the initial idea but may be bound by certain rules restricting the freedom to let the work of art evolve during its creation.

lisa-belding-fear-fun-with-acrylic-paintingAs I read through my answers I come to realise how subjective art is and how we view a piece of art can be down to the context we see it in – the urban sketch by Debbie Thornhill of the Women’s March could be deemed to be propaganda if it was seen amongst many others, particularly those who are very supportive of their political cause or it could be seen to be just that visual record if seen with other non-related pieces.

This painting by Lisa Bellfield, a fellow member in a Facebook group and who has also given kind permission to share, was painted the night President Trump got elected and like Debbie’s work could be seen in two entirely different contexts.  It is a visual record of the emotions of the artist and this is for me personally the goal of art and it encompasses art into everyday life.  The more I become involved in the art world and the more passionate I become about art the more I begin to realise that art should be autonomous but it should not be separate from everyday life because it records every day life.  Art can be propaganda in its entirety or it can show the fear of an artist who is worried for the future as a new era in her country’s political future begins – Lisa’s piece would no doubt have been done by someone which ever candidate had been elected. Art can also simply be there to serve the function of recording a visual scene such as the one of by David Lowther,  done to raise funds for a new church or community building roof or simply for the fact that a rose is too beautiful not to paint.

As a footnote propaganda art can be seen as a motivational tool or promoting solidarity and in the World War II it encouraged American to buy war bonds which were crucial to their war effort and in the UK the propaganda posters and art encouraged rationing or encouraged people to be discreet in what they said or vigilant in their movements due to safety concerns and it was highly necessary.  The word  ‘propaganda’ has started to have negative connotations and seen in a very narrow viewpoint and this includes the art but it can be used very much for the good because art is a visual tool that does not need words and at this point I refer back to the stained glass windows and art of the Catholic Counter Reformation or the stained glass windows of even St Mary’s Catholic Church by Pugin  here in Derby, which was built much later in the 19th century,  which were done to inspire devotion particularly combined with the gargoyles on the outside which told the congregation of the sins outside of the building – effectively those carvings were to scare the people into the church whereby they were confronted by the religious images and in effect all were propaganda!

 

Posted in Coursework, Notes, Part 5, Research & Reflection | 1 Comment

Tutor Report on Assignment 5 with my response

My responses to my tutor’s feedback are in italic font throughout the report.

Overall Comments

Thank you for your final assignment and well done for completing the course!

This submission demonstrates accurate knowledge and manipulation of key ideas. You have developed your acuity in observing, identifying, and analysing visual culture, and you have also displayed good working habits (such as the keeping of a learning blog).

I would recommend trying to demonstrate more awareness of underlying theoretical/methodological issues (and their wider significance). You should also try to expand your analytical comments – make sure your observations are critical rather than overly descriptive. Check through your written work to eliminate examples of simple assertion/opinion that are not supported or sustained by evidence.

I have gone through my blog and checked my work in accordance with this advice and also tried to expand or develop the issues or comments my tutor has suggested.

You will need to clearly show your assessors that you have attempted to synthesise and reflect upon a range of research sources. The more you can display your ability to engage constructively with art historical arguments/debates to inform your essay, projects, annotations, and learning blog, the more likely you are to pass at assessment.

Again I have gone through my blog and tried to reflect on a range of different research sources although I am aware of the limitations due to simply not being able to access the range I would have liked.  I believe I have demonstrated an ability now to engage in art historical annotations in my annotations, essays etc – I can see a definitive learning curve throughout the course now and certainly have improved in confidence.

There are a number of areas that I would encourage you to rework or expand on in relation to this assignment, which I will outline below. In particular, see my comments on your review.

Feedback on Assignment

Assignment 5

Reading notes

General: Some of the themes central to artists in the period from 1900 to 1950 are listed below – check that you have covered them:

 Art as more than a mere visual representation of objective reality: why is there such a shift in the visuality of art around 1900? What motivating factors are there?

 Art as the depiction of modernity: how do representations of the modern city often define modern art? What sorts of visual tropes allow us to discern an artist’s attitude toward modernity and the new city?

 Art as a means of social or political engagement: how does art continue—from a trajectory started in the middle of the nineteenth century—to approach issues of social justice or to allow politics into its form and subject matter?

 Art as a reflection of history: how do historical events or changes direct the course of art in the early twentieth century?

I have taken these questions into account and either answered them directly at the end of my notes or they have been answered separately in additional blogs.

1900-1919

Given Modernism’s penchant for short-lived movements preceded by manifestos that expressed their unique aims, Caws’ Manifesto: A Century of Isms (Omaha: University of Nebraska Press, 2000) may be a useful source if you would like to read such groundbreaking works as the “Founding and Manifesto of Futurism” by Marinetti.

As you stated, the Post-Impressionist Cézanne was credited by two of Modernism’s pioneers—Matisse and Picasso—for laying the groundwork for twentieth-century art. Among other things, his depiction of objects from multiple viewpoints and his use of colour as a building block for form (rather than as a necessary attribute of form) led both to the fracturing of form in Picasso’s Cubism and the use of arbitrary (non-naturalistic) colour in Matisse’s Fauvism.

While some critics recognised the passion and vitality of Matisse and his followers’ new direction, others challenged Matisse for painting in this radical idiom, and his reaction said a lot about the new territory of Modernism. Responding to charges of ugliness made about his Blue Nude of 1907, Matisse famously quipped: “If I met such a woman in the street, I should run away in terror. Above all, I do not create a woman, I make a picture.” As you hinted, this idea—that art could be about something greater than mere representation—marked a radical shift that was taken up by two of Modernism’s major movements, Expressionism (ref. Kandinsky’s use of colour and form to express internal/extra-pictorial qualities such as spirituality and emotion) and Cubism (e.g. the hard geometry underlying Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d’Avignon [and the use of Primitivism to find new forms of expression]).

In thinking about how the visual innovations of Cubism and Expressionism catalyzed artists across Europe who sought to express the modern age in their art, you referred to the way in which Italian (and later, Russian) Futurism embraced modernity, specifically seeking to incorporate advances from science and industry into their multifaceted production. (Ref. the Futurists belief in the concept of simultaneity.)

It is important to consider that there are very different demands, limitations, and criteria when it comes to architectural innovation and history. Architecture in the twentieth century is a huge topic, so it was good to see you concentrate on two brief architectural narratives originating in the United States and Europe – the International Style and the designs of Frank Lloyd Wright. (Lloyd Wright fervently critiqued the International Style and this critique was revived, mid-century, in the multifaceted designs of Postmodernism—which, again, tried to break open the International Style’s ‘glass box’.)

I pay particular attention to the last paragraph due to having worked for an architect and it is interesting to study the differing styles of the last century and I note the differing demands, criteria and limitations which my tutor states. 

Between the two World Wars

It is worth emphasising that in the arts, there was a decided shift following World War I toward concepts of order, harmony, and beauty to counteract the chaos, division, and ugliness of the war machine. This is not to say, however, that all attempts at postwar organisation and harmony were retreats. Some of the most radical abstraction that Modernism featured was also built around principles of simplicity, order, and functionality. (Ref. Neoplasticism and Constructivism.)

As you indicated, a set of ideas more than a coherent movement, Dada has been referred to as an ‘anti-art’ movement due to its iconoclastic nature and its tendency to critique and question the very principles underlying the commissioning, creation, and dissemination of art. Dada stood for an embrace of the irrational and original versus traditional concepts of reason and tradition, and Duchamp’s Fountain raises a number of important questions regarding the status of art itself. What is a work of art? Who gets to decide? If the artist gets to decide what a work of art is, then is choosing a work of art significantly different than creating it? Can an idea—not an object—be a work of art?

I have answered the questions my tutor mentions at the end of my blog in reference to my own opinions which I have considered carefully and in context.  

You clearly outlined how, following the philosophical concepts of psychologists like Freud, Surrealism claimed precedence for the irrational, for chance, for the uncanny, and for the unconscious, which it sought to connect with through automatism and the interpretation of dreams.

Your comment on Diego Rivera was good, but try to reflect on the ways that artistic representation expresses cultural values. For example, in the 1920s when muralism began, there was a concern with defining a new ‘Mexican’ character. This often led to themes of mestizaje (celebration of Mexico’s mixed-race heritage), but also recognition of the native value of the indigenous Indian. Stemming from a 1921 manifesto written by Siqueiros, muralism was pitched as an art of social and political engagement. So, muralism provides a chance to talk about the intersection of art and politics. What is the goal of art? To what extent is art supposed to be autonomous and separated from everyday life? Does art that has a function cross the line from art to propaganda, or is there a hazier area between the two? Another major theme to discuss is the value of public art in society. What does public art accomplish? If muralism is monumental and public, how are its conditions different than small, private works of art that are made for consumption by the art market and institutions like museums?

I have answered this paragraph and my tutor’s questions in a separate blog which can be seen at:  https://theinquisitivebunny47.wordpress.com/2017/01/22/questions-posed-regarding-ways-that-artistic-representation-expresses-cultural-values-tutor-report-assignment-5/

Bauhaus was a revolutionary new take on the traditional art school model, bringing the fine arts and the applied arts under one roof and one curriculum. Can you say a bit about the architectural design of the Bauhaus? Look at Gropius’ Workshop Wing, created in Dessau in 1925–6. Here, ‘form follows function’ is taken to its logical extreme, with no superfluous additions. Gropius adopted new industrial materials and, with the added support of steel, introduced the glass curtain wall. This pared down aesthetic could also be related to the ideals of Modernism, such as the streamlined aesthetic of Piet Mondrian’s De Stijl movement, which attempted to find the universal essence of painting. Like Mondrian, Gropius’s ‘honest’ approach attempted to express the essence of these new industrial materials without hiding them behind decoration.

I have said a little more, as suggested, about the architectural design of Bauhaus at the end of the relevant blog and understand my tutor’s points.

In terms of the history of photography, how have twentieth-century photographers balanced the camera’s capacity for documentation with its aesthetic possibilities in order to convey a variety of social and cultural messages? In particular, explore further Dorothea Lange’s photographs. This Getty video is a useful resource: http://www.getty.edu/art/collection/video/399923/dorothea-lange’s-documentaryphotographs/ Think about Lange’s Migrant Mother – what makes this photograph iconic? How does it relate to other images you have seen? A thought-provoking article you might like to look at is Stein’s “Passing Likeness: Dorothea Lange’s Migrant Mother and the Paradox of Iconicity”: https://zscalarts.files.wordpress.com/2013/12/passing-likeness_0012.pdf Consider how the meaning of a photograph is constructed, and how meaning might change through time or in a particular context. What is the value of documentary photography?

This is another paragraph I decided to answer as a totally separate blog and this can be seen at:  https://theinquisitivebunny47.wordpress.com/2017/01/22/question-how-have-twentieth-century-photographers-balanced-the-cameras-capacity-for-documentation-with-its-aesthetic-possibilities-in-order-to-convey-a-variety-of-social-and-cultural-messages/

Post War to Post Modern

Try to focus on the fundamental questions of art history as they apply to contemporary art:

 What motivated artists to develop new artistic styles and practices in the midtwentieth century?

 How have these historical developments influenced the production of art today?

 How does contemporary art build upon, and depart from, its historical precedents?

I have directly answered these questions in brief at the end of the relevant blog and it was interesting to consider my answers.

Your section on Abstract Expressionism was solid, and you briefly underlined the fact that the genesis of this ‘school’ of artists was built upon a number of motivators. (I.e. many of its artists were influenced by the large-scale works of the Mexican mural movement and the WPA mural project that derived from it. The arrival of a large number of avant-garde artist-refugees from Nazi-occupied areas of Europe in the 1930s brought new techniques and philosophies. Additionally, the growing cultural milieu created by earlier New York City artists set the stage for this ‘next big thing’.)

You alluded to Pollock’s ‘drip paintings’. Pushing painting to the limits of two-dimensionality and non-objectivity prescribed by earlier artists like Mondrian, consider how Pollock and his cohorts imbued their canvases with psychological and emotional values, trying to reach something of a chaotic, primal human universality in the wake of WWII rather than the precise, orderly geometric universality of the preWWII avant-garde.

Your notes on the Colour Imagists (or Colour Field painters) Mark Rothko and Barnett Newman highlighted the metaphysical dimensions of the movement, but bear in mind its relationship to the historical sublime too. (This connection can be demonstrated through comparison to nineteenth century Romantic landscape painting, which encouraged viewers to contemplate their place in the vastness of nature, while Colour Imagists relied on expansive canvasses awash in fields of colour to generate similar responses among their audience.)

You included some useful information on Rauschenberg’s ‘combine’ paintings and Jasper Johns’ paintings of popular subjects like flags that collapsed the distance between the real object and its artistic representation. Similarly, it was good to see you refer to works by Warhol, Lichtenstein, and Oldenburg, which exemplify the subjects and techniques of American Pop Art, as well as the movement’s relationship to mass production and consumer culture. (Note that Pop Art and Minimalism emerged in a broad context of social unrest, characterised by student protests, anti-war sentiments, and the rise of the Feminist, Civil, and Gay Rights movements.)

For information on Conceptual art, see the seminal 1968 essay “The Dematerialization of Art,” by Lucy Lippard and John Chandler, which acknowledges the shift away from painting and sculpture in favour of art that emphasizes creative process over the final object: http://cast.b-ap.net/arc619f11/wpcontent/uploads/sites/8/2011/09/lippard-theDematerializationofArt.pdf

Unfortunately this pdf is no longer available as it has been archived or suspended.

Given that the body appears as a key theme in much art of the late twentieth century for artists interested in issues of identity, physical perception, and human interaction, try to have a look at works such as Marina Abramovic’s Rhythm 0 (1974): https://vimeo.com/71952791

I have watched that video and found it difficult emotionally but also fascinated as Marina Abramovic became not a person but an artistic object to the public who could not longer cope when she reverted back to her personality again as she herself stated – she puts herself as a piece of art to be created and lost her identity and discovered different ways in which she was perceived.  I found it disturbing that she was cut and also the bullet was put in the gun but considering the world in which we live now with its instability I question what would happen if this artistic experiment was repeated some 43 years later i.e. now in 2017 as opposed to 1974 when it was originally filmed.  The fact that someone put a rose between her hands, someone cut or took her blouse off and revealed her body and someone else wrote on her is fascinating and shows the different ways the human body is perceived and how we do interact with each other and that this point I must consider the fact this was filmed over 40 years ago and take into context the era and the different political times – the 1960’s were about freedom and expression for many and this experiment has echoes of that because each person who interacted with Marina was expressing something within themselves.

As you noted, Robert Smithson’s Spiral Jetty (1970) serves as a canonical example of earth art, highlighting the emphasis on process, site-specificity, and broader questions around institutional context, geologic time, and mankind’s place in nature. For a short, general introduction to Feminist art (and a lively polemic!), see Blake Gopnik’s 2007 review of the exhibition Wack!: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wpdyn/content/article/2007/04/20/AR2007042000400_pf.html

Artists and images worth discussing include Cindy Sherman’s series Untitled Film Stills and Barbara Kruger’s collages (which address the history of the gaze in art, and often, like Sherman’s photography, use the visual lexicon of mass-media imagery to critique the systems that it reproduces, such as sexism and capitalism).

Unfortunately again the page suggested is no longer available but I understand my tutor’s points and also in reference to Cindy Sherman and Barbara Kruger.

A summary of the significant topics addressed in all three chapters could concentrate on:

 Art as social commentary

 Art as cultural property

 How politics shape art and art shapes politics

 Learning about the past to inform the present and shape the future

Annotated Images

*Try to refer to a wider range of sources – do not over-rely on material from the internet.

Braque – Houses at L’Estaque:

This was a solid annotation of a Cubist work that covered most of the principal features, including: the use of flat (toned-down) areas of colour (sober browns, dull greens and greys) borrowed from Cézanne; the shallow/compressed space; the simplified, fractured geometric forms; the grid-like structure.

As you noted, Braque breaks with the fundamental conventions of picture making to give the composition a fluctuating and elusive quality. This is neatly summed up by Golding, who states that “the picture plane is emphasised by the complete lack of aerial perspective…and by the fact that occasionally contours are broken and forms opened up into each other. There is no central vanishing point; indeed in many of the houses all the canons of traditional perspective are completely broken.”

I am happy with my tutor’s response to this annotation particularly considering I did not find Cubism easy to understand initially.

Derain – Le pont de Charing Cross:

You recorded the way in which the canvas, true to the aims of Fauvism (specifically, the aim of ‘liberating colour’ to give it greater emotional and expressive power) glows with intense, large, flat areas of colour (typically mosaic-like dashes of unmixed paint directly from the tube) utterly divorced from naturalistic description. So, you mentioned Derain’s use of complementary colours (e.g. oranges and blues), how the shadows in the piece are created by the extreme variations of colour, and the bright hues employed to form bold outlines.

In addition to the kinds of marks made on the surface of the canvas, think a bit more about the artist’s concern with volume and form, and the grouping of broadly suggested shapes to create harmony or a special rhythm. (The space is decoratively ‘staged’ – the organising principle of the arabesque is paramount.)

Note how Derain reflected the most important influences affecting the Parisian avantgarde (Symbolism, Neo-Impressionism, Gauguin, Cézanne, Matisse, Picasso, non-western art).

In terms of process, it is worth noting that Derain did not paint his views of London on the spot. The discovery of two sketchbooks with drawings and colour notations that match the compositions of the London views suggests that Derain drew each scene from nature but then painted the pictures back in his studio in Paris.

Your compare and contrast section was good, and you seemed to respond positively to Derain’s attempt to fundamentally reorganize our perceptual responses. (I.e. colour loses any sense that it is being used to capture the texture of one moment in time – it ceases to be presented as the quality of an object, meaning the relation of expression to experience is fragmented and left open to question.)

I have taken on board my tutor’s suggestions about thinking more about Derain’s concern with volume and form etc and adjusted my annotation accordingly.  I have also added a note regarding the fact he did not paint his views in London on location but rather back in the studio.

Analysis – Hamilton’s ‘Just what is it that makes today’s homes so different, so appealing?’ & Gonzalvez’s ‘Do Angels cry?’

Generally, this was a sound piece of writing based on an interesting choice of artworks. However, I would encourage you to consult and utilise more effectively a few extra sources to address central aspects of the two pieces. This should also help you to clearly identify the links or differences between the works so that you can build a logical and meaningful set of responses.

Your paragraph on Hamilton’s collage was good, and you outlined the way in which the image acts as a compendium of luxury items and exotica identified with modern life in North America but still rare in postwar Britain (e.g. a large-screen television set, a giant tinned ham, a tape recorder, and a far-reaching vacuum cleaner). Note details such as the table lamp decorated with the Ford insignia that establish the transatlantic origins of Hamilton’s dream world, in which every imaginable appetite can be satisfied instantly.

Hamilton’s collage presents a vision of the future in which a modern Hercules, with a giant lollipop in place of the traditional club, enjoys a life of perpetual, easy pleasure. How does Gonzalvez’s photograph respond to and challenge this work? Begin by looking at Gonzalvez’s comments on the portrait – she remarks that she has “become far less materialistic” since she started producing her intimate, powerful records of life on the street.

You described the ex-military man’s wrinkles and referred to the idea of London’s forgotten population, but make sure you have covered elements such as the lighting (tone, contrast), angles, scale, perspective (including depth of field), texture, and composition (the arrangement of different elements/the methods and techniques used by the photographer – cropping, containment/confinement).

I have amended my analysis taking on board these comments and questions although my amendments have taken me over the required word limit.  

Review – A biographical analysis of the art of Artemisia Gentileschi

Ensure that the presentation of your material conforms to the accepted conventions of good academic practice – e.g. full reference list, appropriate tone, use of good quality images with complete captions. Each illustration you use should be captioned using this layout (or a version similar to it): Figure number, Artist, Title (in Italics), Date, Materials, size, Collection or location.

For the purposes of Formal Assessment, when you will need to produce a Word document/hard copy, check that the pages of your essay are numbered, that you have left a space between each paragraph, that you have used 1.5 or double line spacing, and that your text is in a readable 12 point font (e.g. Times New Roman or Arial).

I have checked through my analysis very thoroughly to ensure everything conforms with good academic practice.

General Points:

Vocabulary – should be varied, precise and apt

Spelling – check technical, specialist terms in particular

Grammar – Sentence structure should be varied; not too simple, nor too convoluted Structure – Have you used signpost words (‘but’, ‘however’, ‘although’ etc.) appropriately, to give your essay cohesion? Have you generally signposted where you are taking your reader (‘There are two points here…’, ‘Having covered…’ etc.)?

As I indicated in my previous comments, writing an art history essay involves creating an argument about what you see (e.g. using the terms ‘how’ or ‘why’ in the essay title). (Something like ‘To what extent are Artemisia Gentileschi’s paintings autobiographical?’ might work better.) Make sure you have developed an interpretive thesis based on close visual analysis of the artworks.

I decided to use my tutor’s suggestion for my title and have also checked the vocabularly, spelling etc.

Your text could benefit from reference to more of a range of sources (books, journal articles etc.) and art historical approaches, which need to be acknowledged in the body of your essay. For example, you referred to Bal and Garrard in your bibliography, but these sources were not mentioned in your text!

I have amended my essay and Garrad is now cited although I could not pinpoint Bal precisely but have cited a third author in the correct manner my tutor mentions below.

Citing sources within the text of an essay: When making reference to an author’s work in your text, their name is followed by the year of publication of their work. Where you are mentioning a particular part of the work, and making direct reference to this, a page reference should be included. E.g. Garrard (1991) argues that… OR for quotations: “Quotation” (Garrard, 1991, p.200). You must also indicate a source even when paraphrasing. If you want to include text from a published work in your essay then the sentence(s) must be included within quotation marks. The quotation should also be emphasised (especially if it runs to 50 words or more) by indenting it.

I have been through my essay as I have re-worked it I have taken note of my tutor’s advice and amended accordingly.

It was good to see that you had formulated a punchy first sentence to get the reader interested and to open up an area for debate within the subject, but think further about the main section of your essay. This is where you lay out your response, mixing argument with supporting evidence (facts, illustrations, quotations). Try to see it as a series of points, each to be developed in a separate paragraph, though there should be an overall thread linking the points in a thematic way. As you know, a long biography of the artist’s life is NOT what is required, so you may need to reread and ‘tweak’ some sections accordingly.

I have tweaked the paragraph relating to Artemisia’s life and also considered the main section of my essay taking note of this advice accordingly.

Investigation, knowledge and understanding of the topic studied: You provided a good overview of the artist’s life and career, covering her training in her father’s workshop, the influence of Caravaggio’s style and dramatic treatment of psychologically intense subjects (although it is important to trace the iconographic similarities of Artemisia’s work to Caravaggio’s Judith Decapitating Holofernes, do not spend too long on this), her study of perspective with her father’s collaborator Agostino Tassi who raped her, and the trial of Tassi which involved Artemisia being tortured and a series of counter-allegations being made against her chastity.

Your scrutiny of the two versions of Artemisia’s Judith and Holofernes recorded the source material (the Apocryphal text of the Jewish heroine which tells the story of a political execution) and key compositional elements, but a slightly more searching approach to visual analysis would have been useful. In relation to the 1620 version you mentioned details such as how the colours are brought into an overall harmony of gold and deep red, and the artist’s use of black glazes to create the shadows, but try to expand on Artemisia’s pentimento (indicating that she altered Holofernes’ drapery to reveal slightly more of his right leg), or how blood spurts out of the wound in distinct curves. (Ward Bissell argues that is likely that in Artemisia’s determination to be utterly convincing and to startle, she “looked to memories of animals being slaughtered in the marketplace and to the arcs of spurting blood in Rubens’ ‘Judith Decapitating Holofernes’”.)

I have expanded on Artemisia’s pentimento as suggested and also tried to have a more searching approach to the visual analysis in my amended essay.

How convincing do you find the argument that the prominence given to the bed refers to the fact that in Latin the bed is called a lectulus, and therefore can be understood simultaneously as a nuptial bed, as a dining couch (with Holofernes’ body likened to the display of meat in a butcher’s shop), and as a bier?

I have addressed this argument in my essay and found it an interesting one to consider.

Your note registering Artemisia’s adoption of a more theatrical but also more sophisticated visual language, demonstrated in decorative and elaborate details relating to lavish costume and jewellery, was good.

Try to say a bit more about the way in which the lives and legends of exemplary individuals like Judith were highly popular at the time with artists and patrons alike. (The very idea of a female of exceptional strength and daring appealed to a seventeenth-century taste for the marvelous.) Think about how Judith also played a significant role within Counter-Reformation Catholicism, in terms of her association with the Virgin Mary and the battle against religious heresy.

I have taken these comments on board and adjusted my essay accordingly.

You briefly considered Artemisia’s paintings in relation to conflicting theories and compulsively biographic or psychoanalytical readings such as Garrard’s speculation that Artemisia’s art externalizes her need to revenge her brutal treatment by Tassi and all men. (Ref. painting as an act of emotional catharsis/means of carrying out psychic vengeance, in an equation described by Garrard as “both biblical and Freudian, linking decapitation and castration – the just punishment for rape in an eye-for-an-eye tradition”.)

However, you need to evaluate this line of reasoning. Read and reflect on Salomon’s statement (in The Art Historical Canon: Sins of Omission): “Whereas Vasari used the device of biography to individualise and mythify the works of artistic men, the same device has a profoundly different effect when applied to women. The details of a man’s biography are conveyed as the measure of the ‘universal’, applicable to all mankind; in the male genius, they are simply heightened and intensified. In contrast, the details of a woman’s biography are used to underscore the idea that she is an exception; they apply only to make her an interesting case. Her art is reduced to a visual record of her personal and psychological makeup.”

I have evaluated the above reasoning and addressed it directly in my essay.

See also Pollock’s criticism of Garrard’s model – she says that “For my money Gentileschi’s painting of Judith and Holofernes has nothing to do with her life experience… What is being so calculatedly decapitated here is the art of these artistic ‘fathers’…” (I.e. To what extent do you think Judith Slaying Holofernes provided a means for Artemisia to structure her desire for a certain kind of artistic identity?)

Pollock also poses some important questions, such as ‘How do I know that what I take to be the signs of a woman artist’s consciousness at work are not merely the imposition of culturally stereotyped ideas of social femininity that have shaped me, that define ‘woman’ in my own time and culture, in my own class and ethnic background?’ (I.e. we need to be conscious of what we are looking for and what we see in the work of women artists.)

I was unable to find Pollock’s criticism on Garrard’s model and also his questions but I have still been able to address his comments in my essay in an appropriate way.

Go over your conclusion again. The conclusion is where you pull together and restate the main points of your essay in order to make some overall statement in response to the question/title. Checklist: What general inferences can you draw from your argument (i.e. conclude, do not just summarise)? Where do you stand in relation to your case? To round off, can you very briefly place your response in a wider context?

I have changed my conclusion completely and feel I have responded to my title and pulled my arguments together with a definitive answer.   

Learning Logs or Blogs

It was good to see you include on your blog more notes on useful programmes and newspaper articles that you have consulted, and your gallery reviews and visit write-ups show how your understanding of the subject and related issues has developed.

As your remarks revealed, despite finding aspects of the material challenging, you have experienced the study of art as an enjoyable and rewarding activity, and have found the course useful. You have increased your appreciation for the process of making and displaying art and by recording your progress against the assessment criteria you have maintained a more reflective stance.

In terms of showing how you have become more of an active and aware learner, you might like to respond to some of the following questions: Which aspects of your work on this course did you think were most successful? How have you used and evolved your critical thinking skills? Do you think you are more confident in discussing aesthetics/using visual language? How would you judge your fluency in new ways of thinking, working, reasoning, and investigating? How difficult was it to use different techniques/approaches in your studies?

 

Suggested reading/viewing

Arnason, H.H. & Mansfield, E. C. (2012) History of Modern Art. 7th edition. New York: Pearson

Danchev, A. (2012) Georges Braque: A Life. New York: Arcade Publishing

Stiles, K. & Selz, P. (2012) Theories and Documents of Contemporary Art: A Sourcebook of Artists’ Writings. 2 nd edition. Berkeley: University of California Press

Pointers for the next assignment

N/A. I hope that everything goes smoothly in the preparation and submission of your work for formal assessment. (Carefully read through the guidelines.)

The main points to think about include:

 Reviewing and reworking material prior to assessment: Check that all your annotations are as detailed as possible and that your projects are appropriately illustrated. As previously discussed, if you are making substantial changes/amendments in light of tutor feedback, briefly acknowledge that some revision has taken place. (Do not duplicate material.)

 Presenting your work to best advantage: Assessors will be looking for evidence that you have engaged with professional standards not only in the production of your work but also in the presentation of it. Include a clear contents list, label every piece of work (include your name and student number) and state which assignment it relates to. Record word counts and use the Harvard Referencing system. Ensure that your blog is carefully organised (e.g. into categories – visits, reviews, essays, reflections, reading notes etc).

I wish you luck in your future studies and do hope you continue to enjoy Art History.

I have taken a comprehensive note of all of this feedback and amended my blogs accordingly throughout as well as checking as thoroughly as possible of all my blogs for all the points and advice my tutor has mentioned.  

There is no question of the fact my love of Art History will continue long after this course has been assessed and will form a vital part of my studies in the future.

Posted in Tutor Reports | Leave a comment

Question asked in Tutor report for Assignment 5 – “How have twentieth-century photographers balanced the camera’s capacity for documentation with its aesthetic possibilities in order to convey a variety of social and cultural messages?”

This is a question that was posed by my tutor in my feedback to Assignment 5 and feel this deserved a separate blog.

My tutor advised me to look at the Getty video on Dorothy Lange’s photographs and also her image Migrant Mother and I was considering doing a separate blog comparing her work of the Great Depression with my own brother’s portraits of the homeless in his adopted town of Frederick, Maryland, USA and also making reference to  Shine Gonzalvez’s work regarding the homeless in the UK.

Dorothy Lange was a photographer during the Great Depression and photographed the migrant workers of the era as well as those who had lost jobs and her photographs are a remarkable window into the past and this is particularly so with her iconic image of the migrant mother.  By capturing the images of the Great Depression in American Dorothy Lange documented the suffering of the era in a similar way to which the Romantic artists portrayed the suffering of people in their reportage of events or the Realist artists painted scenes or reality of life which were not always pleasant.

My brother Andrew has photographed many of the homeless people of his community to raise awareness that these people are not just bunches of rags or blankets but real human beings with stories to tell of why they have ended up homeless in a similar way to how Shine Gonzalvez has with her images  – both of these photographers in two different countries are carrying on the work of the documentary photographers of the Great Depression and all those in the intervening years as they photograph the images that are not all pretty and pleasant and palatable but those that are far tougher to see.

If I think of the question regarding aesthetic possibilities in order to convey the social and cultural messages and I look at the work of Dorothy Lange or indeed the work of these two modern photographers I must consider that these are not the aforesaid pretty images but these are hard and at times brutal thought provoking images which no matter how much you want to look away effectively force you to look.  The iconic image of Migrant Mother with her two children looking away from the camera is one that conveys a direct message of despair and worry for the future and  although you want this woman to have hope you see none in her face or eyes – there is nothing beautiful about it but there is a cultural message about the era.

I note that Andrew and Shine have both taken photographs of the homeless in black and white rather than colour and I must presume this is because somehow in colour you loose some of the message you are trying to convey – the black and white allows the features of the face and the eyes of the person to tell their story to the viewer without the distraction of colour or the aesthetic qualities.

So to answer the question fully “how have the twentieth-century photographers balanced the camera’s capacity for documentation with its aesthetic possibilities …. etc” is to say I feel they have the camera’s capacity to document life as they see it, or as life indeed is, no matter how harsh and taken out the aesthetic possibilities in how they have composed the images – anything beautiful that can detract is removed.  Andrew and Shine have the option of many different Photoshop programs or filters at their disposal but Dorothy had essentially dark rooms and cameras that were incredibly basic in comparison to those of the modern era and so she had to consider the light, the composition and the specifics of what mood she wanted to capture or evoke with her photographs were seen by the public.

My last paragraph brings me on to the final question my tutor asks – “Consider how the meaning of a photograph is constructed, and how meaning might change through time or in a particular context.  What is the value of documentary  photography” …

A photograph is constructed and composed often with a specific meaning that the photographer wishes to convey – Dorothy wanted to convey what the Great Depression meant in reality to so many in the same way Shine or Andrew want to get across the message of the lives of the homeless or displaced on the streets today.  A photograph can be effectively composed in a studio or on a stage or it can be taken in a split moment in time which is often what Dorothy did according to the video when she asked for the car which she was a passenger in  to be stopped so she could document another scene or person.  Photographs do change over time with regards to meaning or if you take the context away and there is no question of that – the Migrant mother could be any mother on any of the intervening years since that image was taken, with only the clothing giving the era away, and a viewer could question whether it was taken in France, Germany, England or the USA amongst others and so the context of the Great Depression becomes meaningless as a viewer may just consider it be a mother in despair for a multitude of reasons including perhaps World War II.  That one photograph demonstrates this change of meaning in time or context more  perfectly than any other that I have seen.  Everyone has photographs of their families which at the time portrayed happy scenes but due to arguments or divorce no longer mean the same or hold the same values and this is the same with documentary photography – the emotions or atmosphere or cultural messages that the photographer wanted to evoke will change with time and as the era is seen in an entirely different context.

Often many people will look back on the Great Depression almost through ‘rose coloured spectacles’ in the same way many people romanticize the Wild West when in fact life was tough, it was harsh and it was unrelenting and perhaps that is what ultimately makes the Migrant Mother so iconic because it was all of those and so much more.  Documentary photography captures events and lives in sometimes brutal reality often in very short spaces of time as they capture an image – a painter will view a scene in a very different way to a photographer because the painter spends time noting and sketching if the work is then completed in a studio or spend considerable more time painting a scene as they see it if they work en plein air.  Documentary photographers are now considered a vital part of life with the images they capture and their value cannot be underestimated when you consider the work of people like Dorothy Lange or the photographers of World War I and II as well as the modern day – they capture life around us and the events that make history whether pleasant and aesthetically pleasing or brutal and harsh or anything in between.

Finally as I think of the comparison between Dorothy Langem Andrew and Shine I do not think of the differences but the similarities in the fact they use the camera not to capture purely pleasant images, although I am fully aware of my brother’s outstanding landscape images which he takes more for his own pleasure, but they take photographs of people who are the hidden of society or the downcast or downtrodden and who lives are tough and despairing.  Dorothy Lange used her skills to get the message across the world that the Great Depression was just that – depressing and tough and her images still get that message across with no romanticism.

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

A&E Television Networks, LLC (2017).  Dorothy Lange Photographer (1895-1965) [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.biography.com/people/dorothea-lange-9372993#synopsis

Gonzalvez, S.  (date unknown).  Shine Gonzalvez Photography [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.shinegonzalvezphotography.com/gallery.html

J. Paul Getty Trust. (date unknown).  Dorothy Lange’s Documentary Photographs [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.getty.edu/art/collection/video/399923/dorothea-lange’s-documentary-photographs/

Natural Artistry Photography.  (date unknown)  Personal Projects [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.natural-artistry.com/homeless-friends/

Stein, S. (date unknown).  Passing Likeness Dorothy Lange’s Migrant Mother and the Paradox of Iconicity [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  https://zscalarts.files.wordpress.com/2013/12/passing-likeness_0012.pdf

Posted in Coursework, Notes, Part 5, Research & Reflection | 1 Comment

Comparison between annotations of the Discobolus of Myron and Boxer at Rest

This is a very late edition to my learning log as I have realised that I did not take note of my tutor’s advice in doing this comparison so have decided to rectify that mistake.

img_4450My two annotations for Part 2 of this course are two sculptures who both originated in ancient Greece.  Discobolus is thought to date to 460-440 BC and the Boxer at Rest (Terme Boxer) between 4th century and 2nd century BC – the exact date for this sculpture is still debated.

Please note my image  reproduced here is a photograph of my annotation as my original photograph I took at the Ashmolean Museum of this cast has unfortunately corrupted on my camera card.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Both sculptures are thought to have been done by the lost wax technique and the evidence for this is apparent particularly regarding the Terme Boxer due to the fact he is totally hollow as can be seen through his eye sockets which would have originally had either semi-precious or precious stones inserted.

Myron’s original Discobolus  disappeared during Roman times but not before many copies were made and there are two notable marble copies that survive and the first of which is the 1st century AD marble Discobolus Palombara which was discovered at the Villa Palombara, Esquiline property of the Massimi family.  This version was excavated in 1781 and originally housed at the Palazzo Lancelotti, hence its alternative name the Lancelotti Discobolus, but eventually it was sold to Hitler in 1938 before being eventually returned to the National Museum of Rome in 1948.  The other version of Myron’s sculpture is also a marble copy and is thought to be  2nd century and known as the Townley Discobolus, excavated 1781 at Hadrian’s Villa, Tivoli and named after the eventual purchaser who was one Charles Townley – a point of note is this statue was originally discovered minus his head and the head of another statue discovered nearby. My point with mentioning these marble copies is precisely that – they are marble and the reason for their survival no doubt rests on their material because bronze was often melted down and re-used and this in turn makes the Terme Boxer so remarkable as it is an original bronze sculpture from the 4th – 2nd century BC.

What is interesting to note is that the Terme Boxer was discovered on the Quirinal Hill, near the ancient Baths of Constantine in Rome in 1885 and it is thought that he was intentionally buried there to preserve him from the invading barbarians as the Roman Empire collapsed between the 4th and 6th centuries.  The maker of this sculpture is unknown which compares with knowing of  Myron of Eleutherae the maker of Discobolus.  Myron was said by Pliny to have sculpted the first naturalistic figures and he was also known to have mastered the portrayal of movement and harmony.  However little is known about Myron himself except for what is written by writers, such as Pliny, in the 1st century.

The obvious comparison between the two sculptures is the pose – the Terme Boxer is seated looking at his adversary whilst the Discobolus is an example of the Greek concept of rhythmos which is limbs being  balanced against one another whist encapsulating equilibrium as he literally caught between two movements.

The Terme Boxer is seated at rest on a new plinth and is slightly larger than life sized and clearly a man who has fought many fights  – the sculptor has inlaid copper on his face and torso to give the impression of blood and he also has a cauliflower ear and bruising to his cheek as well as a broken nose.   The boxer wears highly detailed caestus – Roman style boxing gloves consisting of leather strips attached to a ring and wound around the knuckled and fitted with wooden padding which tell of the fact that he must have been a sportsman of some repute due to the simple fact these are the ancient equivalent of knuckledusters and could subsequently be deadly.   He is also a man of considerable muscularity  and fitness and despite his battered appearance he has the air of a fighter albeit one of maturity as is shown by his hair and well kept beard.

In comparison there is the slighter and leaner body of the athlete caught in the middle of pulling back his arm and twisting his body to throw the discus.  The cast incidentally combines a headless statue discovered at Hadrian’s villa with a head of a statue apparently discovered near Rome but the Ashmolean Museum does not make direct reference to whether this is a copy of the Townley Discobolus although it would be reasonable to assume it is.   Myron has carefully incised the lines of the abdomen and groin which results in clear definition of the abdominal muscles which in turn combined with the definition on the hips and chest give the sculpture such a naturalistic appearance.  The athlete is also perfectly proportioned (symmetria) but there is an element of the figure being idealised in the fact the expression on his face is considered too calm and relaxed for what he is doing but I personally consider his face to be concentrating and feel he has a focus on the task in hand.  There is no question of the feeling of anticipation for the movement to continue indicated by the position of his arms and the twisting of his body – his upper body is open and in the midst of the movement whilst his lower body is closed and angular.

Both sculptures are naturalistic and realistic anatomically although somewhat idealised in the pursuit of the portrayal of perfection despite the fact that the boxer is so battered from his fight in appearance.  Myron lead the way in sculpting naturalistic figures and it would be a reasonable assumption to say that this eventually resulted in the almost startlingly realistic Terme Boxer.  There is a question of why the boxer was made – was he made for a patron or as a votive statue dedicated by a boxer at Olympia, was he a singular statue or as part of a group or was he simply just a genre statue or maybe even as a memorial to a boxer of repute.  Unlike Discobolus who was designed to be seen only from the sides on a single plane from the sides, the boxer can be seen from all angles so I personally question where was the boxer was originally displayed.  I also have the same questions for Discobolus – was this part of a group or was it made for a patron and if it was meant to be viewed from a single plane was it displayed on a plinth or perhaps in an alcove at an arena similar to the Colosseum or in a public forum but this is purely conjecture and  the answers for both sculptures are lost in the midst of time.

To summarise I chose two apparently different sculptures with one static looking up at potentially his adversary after a fight and the other caught in a moment between two movements whilst giving a real feeling of movement but the sculptures have distinct similarities in their potential technique and their naturalistic portrayals of a fighter and an athlete. Discobolus is the earlier sculpture by possibly up to 200+ years, or potentially less than 100,  and despite the attention to detail it is clear techniques progressed to produce the astonishing realism of the Terme Boxer including the aforementioned copper inlay in the wounds to give an impression of blood.

I would hope to visit the British Museum in the future to see the Townley Discobolus and likewise I would love to also visit the National Museum of Rome to see the Terme Boxer in person.

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

Ashmolean Museum. (date unknown).  Focus on Greek Sculpture Notes for Secondary School Teachers [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.ashmolean.org/education/resources/resources2011/FocusOnGreekScupltureTeacherNotes

British Museum.  (date unknown).  The Townley Discobolus [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.britishmuseum.org/research/collection_online/collection_object_details.aspx?objectId=8760&partId=1

Butler, S. 2012.  The Discobolus [online]. [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.hiddenhistory.co.uk/antiquities/the-olympics-in-ancient-art/

Encyclopedia of Sculpture. (date unknown).  Myron (active 480-440 BCE) [online]. [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.visual-arts-cork.com/sculpture/myron.htm

Mcdowall, C. 2013.  Ancient Bronze Masterpiece at the Met NY – A Boxer at Rest [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.thecultureconcept.com/ancient-bronze-masterpiece-at-the-met-ny-a-boxer-at-rest

Metropolitan Museum of Art. 2000-2017.  The Boxer:  An Ancient Masterpiece Comes to the Met [online].  [Date Accessed:  January 2017].  Available from:  http://www.metmuseum.org/blogs/now-at-the-met/features/2013/the-boxer

 

Posted in Coursework, Part 2 | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Visit – All Saints’ Church, Kedleston, Derbyshire

img_2662This church was formerly known as St Margaret’s and stands in the grounds of Kedleston Hall near Derby – the hall being the subject of an exercise in Part 4 which required me to visit a Neoclassical house.

Much of my information is derived from the guidebook available to purchase in the church and it is interesting to note the previous name and the current name is an error that it seems is over 250 years old!  There are 2 Saint Margaret’s and the one this church refers to is St Margaret of Antioch of whom little is known apart from the theory that she was martyred due to persecution of the Diocletian, the Roman Emperor in AD 303.

The cult of St Margaret was apparently popular in Western Europe during the 12th Century which ties in with the foundation of this church – the earliest historical record of the church is dated 1198-99 and it finally became redundant in 1983.

I was unaware that The Churches Conservation Trust now owns the church and is a Grade I listed building due to its historic and artistic importance – the latter I do understand having visited now on several occasions.  The church is still a consecrated building and used on special occasions.

The reason for the redundancy has primarily been due to the social and economic changes of the 20th century including the fact that the community that originally resided at Kedleston was removed, along with the priests who lived there and so they lived further away from the church itself – this has been a common factor for many parish churches on the great estates throughout the 20th Century.    The church was closed at around the same time Kedleston Hall was transferred to the National Trust – a new chapter began simultaneously for both buildings historically.

img_2665As I have noted the first mention of the church appears around the end of the 12th century and this south doorway dates from around that period or the early 13th century.

The tympanum above the door is now sadly defaced but on close inspection you can make out the horseman and wild beasts which the guidebook describes – it is clearly medieval in origin and the secular subjects typical of the Romanesque architecture of the era.

An unusual feature of the church is that it is has a cruciform plan which was more commonly found in cathedral or collegiate churches – the builders it seems had grand plans for this building as well as the resources to build it and this also further enables historians to date the origins of the building.  Further evidence of the 13th century building can be found within the church itself including the 4 arches that support the tower as well as some windows.  There is a Memorial Chapel that obscures the original cruciform plan but it is a very obvious later addition.

Like almost all churches from the medieval period the church has undergone improvements over the centuries or changes at least – I am not always sure if ‘improvements’ is the right word in many cases!  There are 2 square headed windows in the south wall from the Perpendicular period of the late 15th or early 16 century with according to the guidebook one only being moved to its current position when the Memorial Chapel was added in 1907 – it seems the top of the tower was also rebuilt in the Perpendicular style at the same time the windows were added.

As a reminder note to myself the Perpendicular style was a vertical linear style with with elaborate and ornate roof vaulting as well as graceful, highly decorated flying buttresses.  Windows had highly pointed arches with the emphasis on expansive areas of glass and also thin but curvaceous stone tracery – the exterior flying buttresses could be crucial in the support of these large openings which reduced the wall space to a minimum.  This style was the last phase in the Gothic style which had lasted until the early 16th century.

The east end of the church faces the house directly and was altered in the early 18th century so that it would be deemed more acceptable – in keeping with the style of the house it has a more classical style.  The guidebook has answered a question regarding the sundial that can be seen – it has the inscription ‘WEE SHALL’ alongside carved stone hourglasses and a central skull and literally invites whoever sees it to complete what is described as a sombre phrase i.e. the pun is ‘sun/soon dial/die all’ (All Saints’ Church, Kedleston, p. 7).

img_2548In the late 19th century Lord Scarsdale employed an architect by the name of John Oldrid Scott to carry out a major restoration removing box pews and also plaster ceilings which had been added during an earlier century.  During this restoration the nave acquired a high-pitched roof and also a stained glass window in the west end which replaced an earlier plain one – the nave walls had to be raised due to the new roof.

This window is stunningly beautiful and I personally cannot imagine a plain one in its place and it brings to mind the windows of St Mary’s Church in nearby Derby which was designed by Augustus Pugin which had been completed in 1839.    The guidebook points to the cusped tracery above the window which echoes the Decorated style of the early 14th century – this is the second phase of the early Gothic period and is literally a decorated style of the style with much more elaborated tracery and architecture including more complex curves and patterns.

img_2621The Memorial Chapel was added in the early part of the 20th century by Lord Curzon who wanted an elaborate memorial to his first wife who had died very young in 1906.  The north wall was removed and this chapel was added and built in Hollington stone.

The architect, G F Bodley, kept the Decorated style of the west window and recreated it in the new windows with ironwork ‘arcade’ replacing the original north wall – this cannot be seen in my photograph due to the fact I pointed my camera carefully through in order to be able to get a clear image of the chapel.

The chapel is highly detailed in terms of carving and symbols with angels carved on the corbels and incredibly fine and elaborate wooden carving.  The floor itself is green adventurine which is a translucent quartz and upon which the black marble plinth of the white Italian marble tomb stands – the latter marble is apparently from Serravezza.  Upon the tomb itself are Lady Curzon’s interests as well as images of Lord Curzon.

img_2647The Memorial Chapel which is the monument to Lord and Lady Curzon is as elaborate and intricate as was clearly intended and also contains a secret which a volunteer pointed out – the floor to one end of the chapel lowers by a hydraulic system to the burial vault below.  During the course of our visit the volunteer showed us photos of the burial vault and informed us that Lord Curzon’s second wife had refused to be buried in the vault alongside his first wife and hence her final resting place is in the small graveyard.

The small door which can be seen in the background of my photograph opens up on to a spiral staircase which apparently leads down to a disused burial vault of earlier origin.

img_2615The majority of the chapel ornaments were obtained from the abroad due to the English versions being destroyed at the time of the Reformation and these include a large but beautiful silver-gilt Portuguese crucifix dated 1640 –  it is believed to have originally been a processional cross.

Other ornaments in the chapel come from Spain and Mexico  and the fact that Lord Curzon equipped the chapel with such items from far off lands also demonstrates how clergy or lay patrons of the Anglo-Catholic churches did likewise and was common at the time.

There are 2 bas-reliefs at the west end of the chapel which I was unable to obtain clear photographs of but are of Italian marble and it seems copies of two that are to be found in the church of S. Maria Maggiore in Rome.

img_2513The rest of the church contains 37 other monuments all  relating to the Curzon family and one of the most interesting is this one – this is a photograph of a photograph displayed on a nearby wall as the actual carved memorials are two roundels sunk into the chancel floor and covered by a wooden covering to protect them at present.  The roundels are incredibly delicate and date from the 13th century – it is believed they may have originally been painted.  The Churches Conservation Trust is hoping to be able to find a way to display the roundels but glass or perspex is not possible due to the strong likelihood of condensation developing and damaging the stone and hence why currently they are covered to protect them.

img_2516In the chancel is also the alabaster effigy believed to be Sir John de Curzon, 10th Lord of Curzon who died in 1406 – there is a question mark over the exact identity of this figure because Lord Curzon it seems preferred a later date of c. 1440.  However the guidebook does state the canopy above the figure dates from the 16th century and this is accepted.  I find it fascinating to contrast this tomb with the one in the Memorial Chapel – the simplicity of the knight in the medieval period as opposed to the elaborate and wealthy tomb of the Victorian period.

img_2563The other large tomb is in the south transept which is the monument to Sir John Curzon who died in 1456 and therefore is medieval.

The male figure on this tomb is depicted in armour with his feet resting on a dog whilst his wife wears a gown and a cloak with a rosary still clear – yes this information comes directly from the guidebook but also from a close study of the tomb itself.  I find this one of the most beautiful and moving tombs I have seen – the detail of the carving is exquisite and there are figures around the base which my fiance and myself were told represented the children of the couple.

In my photograph on the left hand side you can just see another memorial to a later Sir John Curzon and his wife – Sir John died in 1686 and is wife in 1642.   The memorial was apparently erected in 1664 and is very naive in carving and bright in comparison to many others in the church – it was erected after the end of the Civil War and again it is interesting in style when compared with the tomb directly in front.

As stated above there are 37 surviving monuments in the chapel to the Curzon family and this small church is in effect the history of the Kedleston estate itself – it started off as possibly a farm with the owners of Norse origin.  The name Kedleston it seems derives from the Old Norse name of Ketill and also ‘tun’ which was the Old English word for farm. The Danish had arrived in Derbyshire in 873-74 and it is thought that they took over an English farmstead and promptly renamed it. There is certainly mention of a village or settlement in the Domesday book which went by the name of Chetelstune and within 100 years the Pipe Rolls mention a settlement called Ketelstan – this is the same village which over the course of many centuries became this great estate and the surviving village.

My earlier blog, for Part 4 of this course,  on the hall goes further into detail of the history of the Curzon family.

img_2531One of the most striking aspects of the church is the stained glass windows some of which date from the 16th century.

This photograph shows one of 4 panels which depict the Stations of the Cross by Franz Fallenter of Lucerne (1550-1612) and along with a window in the chancel by the same master craftsman were purchased in Switzerland and only installed in the church in 1910.

These windows are exquisite in their colours and it is remarkable that they are survived the subsequent centuries in such condition.  These windows were made during the time of the Catholic Counter-Reformation which also took place in Switzerland in opposition to the Protestant Reformation and these windows are very direct and compelling in their Biblical message.

img_2537The north window of the north transept is in contrast to the Swiss windows very recent in origin as it was only inserted in 1912 and made by one James Powell of London.  The figures of St Chad, St Thomas a Becket and St Nicholas and the 3 figures of St Catherine, St Mary and St Margaret are however based on medieval glass windows that were in the church in the late 17th century and described in documentation.

An aspect of Lord Curzon I do admire is the fact that he seemed intent in restoring much of the medieval aspects of the church as he possibly could and in doing almost brings back the atmosphere of religious devotion from that period in time.

The windows throughout the church inspire religious piety and also speak to the parishioners without the need for words – bearing in mind in many churches the community members were illiterate in the medieval era and subsequent centuries and stained glass windows were used to tell of the biblical stories or of the saints.

img_2564Another window by James Powell and dating to 1890 is in the south window of the south transept and tells of the Ascension of Christ.

What I note about these later windows as opposed to the earlier medieval ones by Franz Fallenter is the more restrained colours and more refined detail.  Franz Fallenter’s windows are brighter and more pictorial with the directness of the Catholic Counter-Reformation whilst the later Victorian and early Edwardian windows by James Powell seem more spiritual in their message in their use of simple colour.  These colours are also seen at St Mary’s in Derby with  the gold colours are representative of the brilliance and splendor of God and the divinity of the Lord, the blue is the life giving qualities of air, sky, hope and healing as well as being representative of the Virgin Mary and the white means purity, virtue and innocence as well as holiness.

I have only covered a very basic history and summary of the interior of this small parish church and feel I have barely scratched the surface – it may be small in size but it is very rich in history.  Kedleston Hall in its present form was effectively built around this church hence its close proximity and I personally feel the church holds the key to the history of the land – it has the history of the family within its walls and grounds and the history of the estate itself.

For me personally All Saints’ Church, or if I am being historically correct I should say St Margaret’s Church and correct the aforementioned 250 year old mistake, is the hidden gem of Kedleston Hall.

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

The Churches Conservation Trust. 2006.  All Saints’ Church, Kedleston, Derbyshire.  London. The Churches Conservation Trust.

 

 

Posted in Research & Reflection, Visits | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Visit – Calke Abbey, Derbyshire

img_1570During September 2016 my fiance and myself visited Calke Abbey near Melbourne in Derbyshire for the first time and first impressions of the house were very high as it is set in the most beautiful grounds and which include formal and kitchen gardens.

As can be seen the house itself is a Baroque mansion built around 1700-02 on the site of Calke Priory which had been founded originally around the 12th Century and occupied until the dissolution of the monasteries by Henry VIII in 1538.

After the aforesaid dissolution of the priory the buildings left the ownership of the church and after going through a series of different owners eventually it was sold to one Henry Harpur in 1622 and the family connection remained until 1999 when the last of the direct line died although the National Trust took over ownership in 1985 in lieu of death duties.

The first grand house on the land after the priory passed out of ecclesiastical ownership was built by one Richard Wendsley after he acquired ownership in 1573-5 and he subsequently sold it to Robert Bainbridge in 1585 and it was his son who then sold it to the aforesaid Henry Harpur.  The Harpur family had their wealth due to a marriage between one Jane Findern  and Richard Harpur combined with his employment as a lawyer and judge.  It is interesting to realise, as I live in Derby, that the Findern family are the ones connected with the village of Findern just to the south of the city which I know well – the family owned the estates and combine this family land with the land that Richard Harpur purchased near Ashbourne, as the guidebook for Calke Abbey states, the foundations of the estates that supported the Harpur family through the subsequent generations were laid.

The majority of the information in this blog is courtesy of the National Trust guidebook due to its comprehensive nature – it is fascinating to read each and understand fully the history of the house, the land and the family that occupied both and throughout my visits around these great houses I have gained a fuller understanding of the area in which has become my adopted home.

As I read through the history I note a fascinating connection with the last house visit I will be writing up before I submit this course for assessment – it seems that Richard Harpur’s eldest son, John, was also a lawyer who served the greatest family in the Midlands during the Elizabethan age and that is the family known as the Talbots or Earls of Shrewsbury.  The 6th Earl Shrewsbury (George) hired John Harpur during his conflicts with his wife who was one Elizabeth Cavendish – the same Elizabeth Cavendish who is better known as Bess of Hardwick of Hardwick Hall.  John Harpur was knighted in 1603 and when he died it comes as no surprise to realise he was one of the wealthiest lawyers in the country.

It is Sir John’s son Henry who purchased the hereditary title of baronet in 1626 and the estate eventually passed to his son Sir John and the guidebook notes that both Sir John’s were Royalists during the Civil War in the 1640’s but failed to hold Swarkestone Bridge – one cousin was resident at Swarkestone and the other at nearby Calke and were subsequently fined before retiring from being involved in further conflicts.  Due to the Swarkestone John dying without heirs the two branches of the family united once more  under the 3rd Baronet (yes also named Sir John – the family used the name along with the name Henry throughout two centuries which I find does get a little confusing if you do not keep track!).  The 4th Baronet succeeded to the title at aged just 15 months – another John and it is he who eventually took over the estates aged 20 in 1701.

Sir John (number 4) also married an heiress – Catherine Crewe in 1702 and built the current house at Calke.  The old building was hugely extended and remodelled as well as formal gardens being added and also extensive new stables too – what I love most about Calke Abbey is these grounds.

However strangely, despite the wealth of the family, Sir John did not become a politician – it was almost expected particularly as he was High Sheriff in 1702-03.  The guidebook points towards a couple of theories – there is an unsociable streak that runs through the family and it is possible he could not stand the thought of the election or there is another possibility that he did not want to compete with his cousin who had been elected in 1701 and 1710 or it could simply have come down to cost as his own High Sheriff office had cost a huge sum at the time and when his son tried to get elected there was another huge outlay which still did not secure the seat.

Sir John’s son inherited the estates and Baronetcy in 1741 and married the daughter of the 2nd Duke of Rutland – Lady Caroline Manners and this marriage introduced him into court circles and eventually the connections meant his election to parliament.  However his political ambitions were cut short when he died in 1748 and his son Sir Henry inherited the family seat.

Sir Henry, 6th Baronet decided to naturalise the formality of the Calke estates gardens and also built a riding school with fields and gallops at Swarkestone – from a personal interest point of view I would love to find out where this is as I am a huge horse lover and used to ride myself.  Sir Henry did become a successful trainer and breeder.

To take a step back to a personality trait – the unsociability – this makes its appearance with the 7th Baronet, another Sir Henry, who was known to be a loner using a term from my own childhood as he enjoyed solitude. Sir Henry became High Sheriff in 1794 and apparently did what was required of him but then caused a scandal when he not only had an affair with a lady’s maid and an illegitimate daughter but then he married her – I cannot help think ‘if only the walls of Calke Abbey could talk’ because there must have been some stories to tell then!!  This marriage meant that the polite society of the time ostracized him – apparently this really didn’t worry him and for that in a modern era I must respect him because it could not have been easy in the social times of his era.

img_1700Sir Henry continued to work on the landscape and also added the Grecian portico on the south front of the house with. This addition of the portico meant that the main entrance of the house was through the door seen in my first photograph at the beginning of this blog – you enter through this door into the room which is both an entrance hall and waiting room with the heads of Longhorn cattle on the walls which Sir Henry had introduced to the estate and which are still bred there today.

img_1690A fishing pavilion was added on one of the ponds and also a grotto which is hidden from view from the house and is really delightful.  The grotto is fed with water from a freshwater spring.

Sir Henry’s liking for solitude extended to communicating with servants through notes which seems incredible in the modern era.  A fascinating fact is that under threat of invasion he recruited a troop of soldiers and then commissioned Joseph Haydn to write two piece of music that they could march to – the original engrave printing plates are still at Calke and are unique in any country house in England.

Sir Henry eventually died in a carriage accident and so the title and the estates were inherited by his son Sir George Crewe who he had banished during his education and for several years afterwards.  The estate was in total disarray and the tenants living and working in appalling conditions and Sir George improved all aspects immediately.  It is Sir George who rebuilt the church on the estate along with that at Ticknall and also built new schools and chapels in the surrounding areas.   There is no question history remembers him as a politician in support of parliamentary reform and it seems he did much good for the people of his communities but the sociability of Sir Henry was to be replaced by the unsociable gene once more that ran in the family with the 9th Baronet – Sir John Harpur Crewe.

This Sir John is  responsible for the start of the collection of taxidermy which in truth my fiance and myself found a little overwhelming – the house is literally stuffed full of it and we were not alone in our feelings as we heard many other visitors say the same.

The gene of unsociability was compounded by the fact that this Sir John married his cousin who was also the granddaughter of the loner baronet and consequentially this eccentricity was to be seen at its height in the 10th Baronet, Sir Vauncey Harpur Crewe.   Sir Vauncey is the man responsible for the feeling that the house has a museum like quality in all the class cases stuffed with everything that nature had – eggs, butterflies, taxidermy animals and birds are just examples.  Sir Vauncey was also another man who lived in isolation despite his marriage – his wife it seems dealt with visitors.

Half of Sir Vauncey’s collections were sold after his death to cover death duties – it staggers me to realise that what is in the house is only half as it really is stuffed full!!  The estate was inherited by Hilda Ethelfrida, Sir Vauncey’s daughter, who had married Godfrey Mosley.

The house now enters its decline because Hilda changed very little except cars were now allowed on the estate and a telephone was installed but little else.  Hilda’s heir was to the son of her younger sister Frances – Charles Jenney  who inherited the estate in 1949 who in turn was not really interested in the house and the estate although he fulfilled his local duties.  It appears that Charles Jenney had inherited the unsociability of his forebearers although he did also fulfill his duties when he became High Sheriff in 1961 which is when he changed his surname to Harpur-Crewe.

The last family member associated with Calke was Charles’s brother Henry who inherited the estate and as I stated at the beginning of this blog it was eventually taken over by the National Trust in lieu of death duties with the support of the government through the National Heritage memorial Fund.

Calke Abbey differs from the other National Trust houses that I have visited because there has been a purposeful decision to not restore it to its former glory but rather to preserve the house in the state of decline in which it was found – its decline throughout the 20th Century is mirrored by many other great houses but it has clung on and survived due to its underlying wealth and behaviour of the family i.e. the reclusivity of the family with their wealth somehow provided a safety barrier from collapse.  The house demonstrates perfectly the decline of the way of life of some of the great families and provides a huge contrast to the houses at Kedleston, Sudbury and even Hardwick and I can understand why the National Trust has chosen to preserve this decline in the way it has although I am not 100% certain it is the right decision.

img_1779The original building built by Richard Wendsley was L-shaped it seems and is now part of the east wing of the current house and also the easternmost part of the north wing according to the guidebook and it is possibly that the east wing is build on the foundations of the original priory or its buildings due to being out of alignment with the later wings.

This photograph is from a hallway in this east wing and it is quite disconcerting as you look up it as the walls are not even and the hall not straight so if it was indeed part of the original priory or built on the foundations of one of the buildings it would come as no surprise.

The guidebook goes into detail about the remodeling including the addition of balustrades to the roof in the late 18th century and the Grecian portico – the capitals are of Ionic styling although with smooth shafts as opposed to the fluted ones you would expect.

img_1735On the east front there used to be a flight of steps leading up to the original entrance hall which is now the Saloon – this is the original door showing the balcony which replaced the steps in front.  The guidebook states that this room may have been a loggia which is a room open to the elements so I question whether the door and windows were there originally and just opened when the weather allowed.

img_1727

 

 

 

The Saloon is a two story room during the 19th Century it essentially became a personal museum for the family and the National Trust has kept it as such – this is the first room I really was unsure about.  I can understand the decision to keep this room essentially as it was used in that period but on the other hand a part of me personally would like a clearer idea of what the room was like when it used originally as the entrance hall – the classical influence is clear with the faux Grecian columns and porticoes which are not just above the doorways but also the fireplace.  This room is unmistakably Neoclassical in its styling and has a grandeur that would have looked magnificent as an entrance hall but feels as if the 9th and 10th Baronet’s have ignored the beauty of the hall due to their love of taxidermy and collecting.  Sir Vauncey turned the estate into a nature reserve and there is no doubt the abundance of wildlife has thrived ever since but I question whether the National Trust could provide, even, in one corner of this hallway a glimpse into what it looked like before his father inherited the house and used some of the estate wildlife in their private collection.

A note of interest is that the ceiling was installed in the 1840’s y Henry Isaac Stevens, a Derby architect who also redesigned the entrance hall – the ceiling has the Harpur boar carved in the plaster work and this is something I will now be looking for on our next visit.  The fireplace in the Saloon was also added during this period so again I question how it would have looked before the glass cases were added.

I have given a brief overview of the history of the house summarised from  information in the guidebook which is comprehensive but it is lacking in information about the individual rooms except – there is a leaflet available and information in each of the rooms at the house but I personally feel this should be in the guidebook itself.

Below are some of the photographs I took as my fiance and myself toured the property with a brief information.

img_1716The Dining Room is typical of the house in that it is largely unchanged since the late 18th Century and is typical of the Neoclassical period in its styling – it is an elaborate room but also is one I did feel has a welcoming feel about it despite the grand entrance through the classical style columns with Ionic capitals which are out of shot in my photograph.

 

img_1726The Breakfast Room was originally the Music Room and dates from around 1810 – personally this was one of my favourite rooms in the whole house perhaps because it did not have any taxidermy in!

I really liked the round table with its marquetry detailing combined with the furnishings and you suspect this was a much used room, if not by the reclusive Baronets but possibly by their wives and families.

img_1752The Library originates from the time of the 7th Baronet and being a lover of antiquarian books this room held a natural fascination for me.  It is obvious here of the family interest in racing due to all the paintings in the room – again this strikes as very much a family room or one which the reclusive owners could hide away in without being disturbed.

As you go around the house there is an air of decay and neglect of times gone by – the house does not feel loved atmospherically but rather that the last owners were disinterested and for me personally I found this incredibly sad because in its day or era it was clearly a very beautiful house although somewhat eclectic.

img_1758

This room is known as the Boudoir – it was originally part of the principal private apartment until the 8th Baronet refurbished his own private apartment and this because his wife’s Sitting Room or Boudoir.

I have not mentioned the art apart from briefly with the racing pictures because there is simply not a huge amount of information available.  Like at Kedleston the owners of the house seem to collect more for their status or alliance rather than the artistic merit of the painters although there are portraits of the occupants or of their great racehorses.  Apparently very few works of art were brought back from the Grand Tours although in the Breakfast Room and also the Drawing Room there are some genre scenes by Dutch painters which the 8th Baronet collected through his art dealer.

The furniture throughout consists of typical items that would appear in any large house of the period – my knowledge here is lacking but there is no doubt there are some stunning Regency pieces which warrant another look on our next visit.

img_1765From this Boudoir you enter the declining areas of the house including the Schoolroom which was created from the 8th Baronet and his wife’s bedroom around 1860.  During World War II army officers used this room whilst they were billeted at the house.

This room really does have the air of dilapidation and it is here you first notice the strong musky scent of damp and notice the decay of the old house everywhere you look and it catches in your throat.  When you look around you can however almost hear the voices of the children educated in this room and imagine how it would have looked.

img_1782Sir Vauncey’s bedroom is one that was apparently found with literally inches of dust in a wardrobe and also holes in the ceiling and roof which had to be repaired very swiftly when the National Trust took over.

This room was literally abandoned and left to decay.

img_1798The room that fascinated me purely for the textiles was Lady Crewe’s Room – the reason for the fascination was the bed covering.  The origins of this embroidery are unknown but the opinion in the literature at Calke Abbey seems to suggest it is from around 1890-1910 and in the Revival Embroidery style.

img_1793Housemaids and servants were taught to sew purely for functional reasons but the daughters and ladies of the house were taught to stitch decorative items and their own designs with inspiration from portraits and nature.

The work on this bedspread is exquisite and I only wish I had been able to get a much closer look or the lighting was a little better.

The room was last used by Charles Harpur-Crewe right up until his death in 1981.

img_1828My final photograph of the house is of the State Bedroom which contains the 18th Century State Bed which is kept in a glass case in controlled conditions.

The bed itself is incredibly beautiful with intricate embroidery and gold-work in stunning colours and it is absolutely right that the National Trust has taken such steps to preserve it.

My photographs have barely scratched the surface with the detail in this house and have only shown about half the rooms which you see on the tour around the property but I have also just wanted to get across the general feel of the place – from entering through grandeur to the preservation of the decline.

I am still unsure over whether this preservation in the decline is right although at the time we visited there was extensive work being done on the inner courtyard areas and the early parts of the house as those were of the highest priority to prevent further decay.  From the comments I heard as we toured the house many visitors would like to see some kind of display on how the house looked at its height even if in just one area of each room or in a display of computer generated images.

img_1557I have barely mentioned the stables or the gardens which are also being preserved and restored.

In the stables there is a collection of carriages which my only complaint is is that the information is not clear enough – it is stuck to one side and in a rather small font which is a shame because there was great interest from our fellow visitors.

img_1572The gardens consist of floral gardens, walled gardens, an Orangery that has been partially restored and also Physic Gardens for the cultivation of medicinal herbs and the Upper Kitchen Gardens  plus the Gardeners Bothy which in essence is the garden potting shed.  I really loved all the different doors which lead from one to another as it felt like you were entering secret gardens and you never knew what you would find.  At the time we visited the Kitchen Gardens had a  gourd tunnel and also some wonderful large pumpkins growing as well as off in one corner behind a small orchard the relatively new addition of some beehives which were clearly fully occupied.

Overall I find Calke Abbey a place that I really enjoyed but have mixed feelings about – I love the house and the grounds are my favourite of all the ones I have visited during the duration of this course but I am just not sure about whether the preservation of the decline of this great house is the right thing or not but only time will give the answer.

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

The National Trust. 2016. Calke Abbey.  Swindon. Pureprint Group.

 

 

Posted in Research & Reflection, Visits | Tagged | Leave a comment

Visit to St. Michael with St. Mary – Melbourne Parish Church

img_3707This visit came about after going to Melbourne for an art trail in September – Melbourne is just over 12 miles from where I live in Derby and yet I had never visited the town and was unaware of the beautiful medieval church.

Please note my information is derived from the guidebook available in the church which has been comprehensively written by the Reverend Frederick Ross.

To give a brief history there is a church mentioned in the Domesday Book of 1066 but the remains of the church have long since one as it was replaced in the 12th century by the current church.  The exact  history of Melbourne itself is lost in the midst of time although it is known to have had a royal castle and Lord Melbourne of Queen Victoria fame gave his name to the city founded in Australia.

Like the history of the town the origins of the current church are unknown but the common theory seems to have been it built by the Bishop of Carlisle – the diocese was certainly founded by King Henry I.  If indeed Adelulf or Aethewulf, the first bishop of Carlisle did build the church it was due to the fact his native town was not a safe place at the time due to the constant warfare on the border with the Scots and so it is thought he found a safe haven in Melbourne after Carlisle was captured in 1136.

img_3788By the 13th century records show that the church was used by bishops to ordain priests and it is this that gives rise to the conclusion that the building of the church would have to have been between 1136 and 1156 when Adelulf was believed to have been a resident in the town.

One unique feature of the church is that it has a two storey arrangement which apparently gives rise to the second theory of why it was built – that of a royal church as part of Henry I’s manor at Melbourne which would have meant that the west gallery was essentially his pew and the upper chancel was for his use but this would have also meant it was already built when Adelulf received it from the King.

img_3708Whatever the origins of the church it is an exceptional example of a 12th century church with all its Norman features with the additional of  of a unique 2 tower facade.  The door on the left has got clear carving surrounding it and is the most beautiful Norman door I have seen during my visits around my locality.  According to the guide book the east end of the church had a triple apse but two have since been removed although evidence does remain both inside and outside of the church.  The church is built in the classic cross shape and has again a unique feature of 3 towers in total.

img_3737I had visited the church as part of the art trail albeit only briefly so knew as my fiance and I entered the church to expect to be in awe of the exquisite architecture but even then it does not prepare you for the first time you look up the nave towards the altar – the rounded arches and solid columns so typical of Norman architecture but combined with the light from exquisite stained glass windows truly gave this church a spirituality I have only previously experienced in cathedrals such as Lincoln which I know well.

img_3726It is interesting to look at the carving of the arches and note the the chevron or lozenge style carving  which was again so typical of the period.

The guide book points out the different capitals on top of the columns – there are cushion, ram’s head, tear drop and figure head and also one capital apparently bears the motif of a cross with 4 roundels which I did take a photograph of but frustratingly it did not turn out clearly enough – apparently the reason for this particular capital has never been explained.

img_3751In the chancel the side walls are Norman whilst the east wall is part of the late medieval rebuilding although my photograph does not show this clearly – I took this image looking through the narthex in order to capture the stained glass window.  In the chancel are the remains of 2 Norman windows and also traces of the stone vault which originally covered the chancel.

The stained glass in the east and south windows is dated 1867 and 1869 so much later and very much in keeping with the religious revival of the period – these years are at the end of the Gothic Revival artistic period. All the stained glass windows within the church are of a similar religious nature and presumably from the same period – they transform the church interior into the lux nova and give an impression of heavenly reflections in the same manner I have witnessed at St Mary’s Church in Derby and luckily on the afternoon we visited the sun shone through the windows to show this effect at its most spiritual.

img_3721The area photographed on the left is one of the areas of the church I spent considerable time in looking up to the central tower in awe of the 3 tiers of triple arches.  According to the guidebook the upper stage was built in the 17th century to house the bells of which the were eventually 4 but now there total 8 with an additional 2 hung in 1882 and then 2 more in 1887 to mark Queen Victoria’s Golden Jubilee – I am not a huge fan of being in churches when bells are ringing due to a type of deafness but for this church I would more than happily make an exception!

The organ built in 1860 and rebuilt in 1981 can just be seen to the left of my photograph as I look back down towards the nave and it is a masterpiece in itself and I would love to hear it being played as the church has beautiful acoustics.

img_3755One thing I personally noted was the carved crucifix in the arches above the central tower facing towards the nave and the congregation almost seems to take the place of the rood screen in smaller churches.  The effect of this crucifix is that it draws the eyes heavenwards and conveys the Biblical message.

img_3726This area is part of the wall-passage combined with the clerestory which is rarely seen in parish churches – this clerestory serves two purposes with one to let in light and the other to give access from the west gallery to the upper chancel. The north and south sides of the church have different arches – the south side of the clerestory has pointed arches and twin lancet windows, (shown in my photograph),  as it was rebuilt in the 13th century by which time Gothic architecture had replaced Norman whilst in the North side the arches are the original Norman rounded style with single windows.

img_3710From a purely art history interest and by this I mean with specific regards to paintings I could not help be fascinated by the  remains of a  Medieval painting depicting the ‘damnation of sinners and their suffering in hell’ (Melbourne Parish Church guidebook).  I had not been aware of the fact that the inside of late Medieval churches would have been adorned with similar imagery and this is the only fragment that has survived only because it was subsequently covered by a plaque.

img_3773Another feature of this church is the architectural style which shows a continental influence including with the carvings on the capitals of the chancel arch  – the Melbourne cat as this carving is known is just one of the several different creatures that can be identified.  The cat is smiling happily because across the chancel is a dog being restrained by a man by his tail desperate to get to the cat but unable to do so – in truth when my fiance and myself saw the dog we could not understand the significance as we did not connect the two carvings!  The guidebook also refers to a ‘sheela-na-gig’ carved onto one of the capitals and this is a pagan symbol regarding female fertility and it is grotesque in its nature but unfortunately I could not take a clear image of it but if my fiance and I return I will try again and add to this blog.

img_3739Near the church door in the narthex section of the church is the 13th century font which is placed there very deliberately as a remind of baptism being the entrance into the Christian church.

The narthex, which goes across the full width of the building at its main entrance,  is one part of 3 unique features of this church with the second being the the west gallery and the third the twin tower facade of the west front – all these unique features are reminiscent of churches on the continent and point to the possibility of a German architect and also the possibility of the church being built for a royal function.

This is without doubt one of the finest Norman churches in England and I have only included some of the architectural and artistic details – unbelievably my camera battery went flat on the day we visited so I was unable to take all the photographs I wanted but I have written this blog to give an overall impression of a stunningly beautiful and architecturally unique church.

The church was hugely restored and altered during the 1800’s and some of those alterations were subsequently removed but the building retains a real feeling of history as you step into it and with a unique spiritual feeling that my fiance and I have not felt in other churches.  The guidebook points to the fact it has the appearance of a mini cathedral but there an intimacy in this church that you rarely feel in such large parish churches and certainly not in cathedrals – it is almost as if you can feel the footsteps of those who have gone before you seeking to worship or possibly seeking sanctuary in troubled times.

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

Ross, F (Reverend). 1992. Melbourne Parish Church.  Great Britain.  Beric Tempest.

Posted in Research & Reflection, Visits | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment